The stupid officials have given me an impression that they push this thing not to convince society, but to show bosses in beijing their loyalty (so that they can secure their posts).
The Devils are in the details. So far I do not see any outright objection to the “National Education” per se. What people object are the contents and the way how to teach it.
Let us take a simple analysis. The left-wing schools will support the “National Education, HK style” for sure. The government schools will be told to support it. The subsidized schools will be influenced to support it in time. What is left? Private schools and international schools? They can do whatever they want without any effect in the big picture. Who can blame 華仁 for their pragmatic approach? Aren’t HK people always pragmatic?
All parents should arm themselves with sufficient knowledge on the subject to counter-balance the “brainwashing”. The challenge seems to be that HK parents are so busy in making a living and have little time for their kids.
老師真的很難教！
回覆刪除不教1949--1966的大陸歷史，學生怎會明白文化大革命的悲劇呢！
歷史應是必修，鑑古知今，沒有更好的國民教育若此。
刪除其實現在真是亂來﹐歷史中史唔洗必修﹐反而高中整科所謂通識﹐將幾專科知識炒埋一碟
刪除國民教育又係﹐中史又唔必修﹐之後將以前的公民科﹑中國近代史同類似中國研究的東東﹐又炒埋一碟
炒埋一碟唔係問題﹐問題係我好懷疑﹐香港D先生真係夠料教﹖
我甚至懷疑好多阿sir同Miss讀大學﹐分分鐘連類似Elementary Logic呢類course都未讀過lor~~
由一個未讀過分析哲學的人教人獨立思考﹐咪即係叫個唔識煮飯的人教煮餸﹐會唔會搞笑少少﹖
I have no worry on youngsters' being "brain washed" considering this internet era.
回覆刪除Teachers giving mere hard (or fake) materials will have no place in this era. While those offering virtue and love education will be respected most.
Students are not as dumb as peking ducks as we were.
同意不一定洗得到，但有人想搞這勾當，就要一開始就打沉他們。
刪除...但有人想搞這勾當，就要一開始就打沉他們...
刪除I cannot agree more.
The stupid officials have given me an impression that they push this thing not to convince society, but to show bosses in beijing their loyalty (so that they can secure their posts).
奇怪...
回覆刪除我朋友做中學老師,他話教局在國民教育科一年只有六萬元資助,根本冇錢可以開到新職位!
可能要現有的阿Sir和Miss食埋。
刪除我想，如果每間學校的國民教育科課程內容都略有出入，各不相同，那麼這科還是不設考試為佳，極其量好像給操行分那樣，教師憑日常的感覺和印象打個等級分就可以了。另一個做法是：規定通識科內有一部分為國情議題，並表明考試中有關國情的問題將大約佔上多少，比方說不超過百分之十，我看已經很足夠了。如果「國教」真的要獨立成科並且被納入考試範圍，我敢說一定勞民傷財，徒令教的人辛苦，學的人也不高興。
回覆刪除「認識國情」，可以。
刪除「認同」這個國情，以及甚麼看到國旗會激動，看到甚麼神九會自豪，那就是另一回事了。
如果要評核，並且以此為基準的話，問題可大了。
Didn't Cardinal Zen say that all Catholic schools over there would not teach National Education next term? What the hack happened with WYHK, man?!
回覆刪除陽奉陰違是中策。
刪除why then WYHK has to do this then, man?! money, or surrender to Sai Wan already?!
刪除其实也不一定就是坏事，我现在还对以前在国内初中学的政治记忆犹新，那个政治老师长得很难看，但很有口才，讲课非常吸引人，即使这样，我也没有被所谓的洗脑，那时候我也经常听美国之音（VOA），也有经常听我的一个亲戚说他在青海流放的经历，各种不同的声音交杂在一起，让我很喜欢思考。任何一种声音都不会是空穴来风，有了解才会有思考和分析的前提基础。
回覆刪除任何情況之下，資訊自由一定要捍衛。
刪除只簡單點説,學校教授不正確、不完整内容教材是絶對有害學習,至於會否洗腦,根椐XX's Law Of Average,不會100％都會,但也不會絶對不會,衹要有ー個孩子會被洗腦,請拿出良心去救救孩子罷！（不過好多人唔識「良心」呢様嘢,太抽像了）。
回覆刪除最要話學生知,什麼叫四兩裝,食足(粥)三餐,瘦肉四兩,有鬼鞋着。四兩粧時我仍在鄉下。即是每人每日食米四兩,双腸飯=二舊蕃薯送飯。現在見蕃薯仍怕怕.
回覆刪除最掉忌是憶苦思甜，覺得現在生活還算不錯，竭力幫這個政府辯護。
刪除深圳愛國保釣大遊行演變成整個停車場日本汽車被推翻破壞公民私有財産,其它日本汽車車主深感無辜損失財産,民警公安坐視不理,港人喜歡下一代變成這様的愛國國民？喜歡就俾個like, OK。
回覆刪除梗係UNLIKE啦，大大個字添！
刪除簡直痴線佢地破壞深圳既日本車包括公安車，人家日本有鬼損失，比UNLIKE= =
刪除同埋依家香港既中學生真係會分分鐘被洗腦，我在fb接觸那些信了中共模式的學生，同初信耶穌一樣，根本石頭一樣。我開始明白點解大家咁緊張國民教育。
班政府高官，公務員和其他教育界高層爲了高薪違背自己良心做事!
回覆刪除是的。
刪除也有不少真心膠。
呢D工作無前景可言(TA/IT) 助理，年年續約唔係長工，人工不高。要應聘要三思!
回覆刪除現在的環境下，不怕無人申請。
刪除有樣野唔明白:點解只教新中國的事,個人認為應該由民國玩起
回覆刪除同意，早一點更好，應該從革命講起。
刪除The Devils are in the details. So far I do not see any outright objection to the “National Education” per se. What people object are the contents and the way how to teach it.
回覆刪除Let us take a simple analysis. The left-wing schools will support the “National Education, HK style” for sure. The government schools will be told to support it. The subsidized schools will be influenced to support it in time. What is left? Private schools and international schools? They can do whatever they want without any effect in the big picture. Who can blame 華仁 for their pragmatic approach? Aren’t HK people always pragmatic?
All parents should arm themselves with sufficient knowledge on the subject to counter-balance the “brainwashing”. The challenge seems to be that HK parents are so busy in making a living and have little time for their kids.
Samson,
Ontario, Canada
可惜是現在還有很多人以為「國民教育英美各國都有啦，都不知道他們反對甚麼？」
刪除講到今時今日，重有家長唔覺洗腦係問題，我就覺得香港人無需去救，有下一代既都唔緊張，我呢啲無牽掛都盡量口誅筆伐，上街遊行，抗議罷課，若果重唔可以喚醒家長，無話可說，等神仙打救。
回覆刪除還是有人說：「全世界都有國民教育啦」、「教會學校講耶耶穌咪一樣！」，真是鄉愿。
刪除